logo
Funny Animals Interesting Freaky Pop Culture

Terrifying Urban Legends That Are Horrifying But True

by Mikayla

Everyone enjoys a good urban myth or legend, they're great for telling around campfires or at birthday sleepovers. But what if the scary stories that you grew up with turned out to be true? The horrifying thing is, most of them are! Most of what we hear are exaggerated stories but myths and legends have to stem from somewhere, right? 

Right, so I'm sure your skin will crawl when you read the real incidents that happened to stem some of the scariest urban legends still around today. Read below stories of murder, creepy children, and myths like Slenderman and finally find out the scary truths behind already terrifying stories.

1. The Buckley Children

Susan and John Buckley beheaded their own mother as part of a Halloween joke. They switched the idea of a beheaded dummy for their actual mother and disappeared before anyone realized that the Halloween decoration was a real dead body.

1. The Buckley ChildrenFreaked

2. Dr. Jacquelyn Kotarac

Dr. Kotarac was found dead after she suffocated after lodging herself into the chimney of her estranged lovers home. She was discovered by a house sitter after the smell became disturbing, and it took a team of firefighters 5 hours to extract the body.2. Dr. Jacquelyn KotaracGuim

3. Michelina Lewandowska

This 27-year-old woman was buried alive in 2011 by her then-fiance. After 'becoming bored' of her, the man taped her up, tasered her and buried her in a cardboard box. She escaped after over an hour by cutting her way out with her own engagement ring.

3. Michelina LewandowskaFreaked

4. Kuchisake-Onna

This is the legend of a woman who was mutilated after her samurai husband caught her cheating on him with another samurai. To punish her, he slit her face from ear to ear and asked her "Who will think you are beautiful now?". People now believe that she wanders the streets wearing a medical mask asking people if they think she is beautiful. Whatever your answer after she removes her mask, she kills you.

4. Kuchisake-OnnaFreaked

5. Black-eyed Children

There have been many accounts of people running into these children with black eyes, mostly related to them needing to be "let in" somewhere. Obviously, people are terrified of these kids, and one of the most recognized stories around them is the story of a Journalist named Brian Bethel, whose car was approached by two of these odd children. After claiming they had missed a movie and needed a ride home they demanded to be let into Brians car. Brian drove off, expecting to see them in his rearview mirror but the two kids had vanished.5. Black-eyed ChildrenFreaked

6. Slenderman

Slenderman is an unnaturally tall figure with no face known to stalk, abduct, or traumatize people, often children. He features in works of fiction, movies, and video games and people who idolize or indulge in works surrounding him have been linked to violent and often fatal acts. It is believed that in the late 2000's he convinced a young girl to commit murder.6. SlendermanKym-cdn

7. Sweet Dreams

On three separate occasions, 1994 in Miami, and 1996 in Pasadena and 2003 in Kansas City, people rented hotel or motel rooms just to be greeted by the sickly sweet stench of decomposing meat. Bodies were later found under the beds of all three.7. Sweet DreamsWp

8. Elisa Day

Eliza Day was a beautiful young girl who was courted by a young man. After presenting her with a rose and convincing her he loved her she went to meet him on the banks of the river where beautiful roses would grow. He waited until her back was turned and hit her repeatedly with a rock as he whispered: "all beauty must die." He placed a rose between her teeth and pushed her body into the water where it was never found again. People now claim that they have seen her ghost walking the banks of the river amongst the flowers.8. Elisa DayFreaked

9. The White Death

The White Death is the legend of a young girl who killed herself. Oddly enough, soon all her family died. According to legend, if you discuss her death she will come knocking on your door to take your life, too.9. The White DeathDewitzphotography

10. Psychic Japan

Psychic Japan was a TV Show that talked about spirits and ghosts and worked to convince people that they existed. Here is a photo that was taken of an audience member looked oddly possessed. Is it possible that the ghosts are trying to blend in as normal people?10. Psychic JapanFreaked

11. The Cooper Family

After moving into a new home the Cooper family decided to celebrate by taking a family photo. When the image of Mother and Grandmother with the kids was developed this ghostly figure could be seen. Whether it's real or not it sure is creepy.11. The Cooper FamilyFreaked

12. Cedar Senai Hospital

In 1972 a young patient escaped from their room and killed two nurses before escaping from the hospital.12. Cedar Senai HospitalFreaked

13. Candle Cult

Numerous murders in Peru 2009 appeared that the victims had had all of their fat drained from their bodies. It is believed that the murders were performed by a cult who then turned the fat into candles and burned them to perform satanic rituals. Men captured from the group also admitted to selling and trading the fat in a human fat trading ring to make things such as perfume and anti-aging cream.13. Candle CultDiariomovil

14. Charlie Noonan

Folklorist Charlie Noonan traveled the US chasing down the origins of bizarre and mysterious stories. His last adventure included finding an odd woman who people had reported seeming "not quite human". She was always followed by a large dog and a disturbing sense of fear. After setting off to find her, Charlie disappeared never to be seen again. His camera was found in a pawn show with only one photo waiting to be developed (see above.)14. Charlie NoonanFreaked

15. The Bunny Man

The Bunny Man legends started in 1970 in Fairfax County, Virginia when stories began about a killer roaming around in a bunny suit killing people with an axe. Most of the stories center around Colchester Overpass, a southern railway overpass that is now commonly referred to a "Bunny Man Bridge".15. The Bunny ManSpokedark

16. The Bunny Man Copy Cat

This picture was found in Georgia, 1982, behind a dumpster. It was handed to the police, but to date, the case remains open and unsolved.16. The Bunny Man Copy CatFreaked

17. Halloween Murder

A 1962 Halloween Party turned from fun to sour when a masked man entered the party with a kitchen knife and proceeded to stab 7 people to death. He fled the scene and was never captured.17. Halloween MurderFreaked

18. Body In A Rug

In 1984 students from Columbia University found a rolled up rug stashed near a dumpster by their building. Thinking they had scored a nice new piece of decor they took it up to their room and prepared to unroll it, just to find a dead body inside. The police were called and found the body of an African American male in his late twenties with two gunshots to the head.18. Body In A RugLibrary

19. No Decoration Is TOO Spooky

In 2005 residents of Delaware were tricked into thinking a hanging body was a Halloween stunt. It wasn't until someone noticed the hanging body was warm and called the police that everyone found out it was a real woman who had chosen to hang herself about a mile from her home.19. No Decoration Is TOO SpookyFreaked

20. Killer recipes

In late October 2009 professional chef David Viens duct-taped his wife's hands, feet, and mouth after getting into an argument. He left her alone for a period of time and when he returned, she was dead. Convinced no one would believe that her death was accidental he stuffed her 105-pound body into a drum of boiling water and cooked her for 4 days until little but her skull was left. He tried to convince her friends that she had left him and sent fake texts off of her phone, but no one believed him and they reported her missing anyway. When the police began closing in on Vienz in 2011 he threw himself off a cliff in an attempt to end his life. He survived the fall but was greatly injured and is now sentenced to serve 15 years to life in prison.20. Killer recipesDailymail

21. Volcanic Ash

The residents on an island off Peru were forced to wear surgical masks at all times because of an active volcano which put them at risk of breathing in dust, ask, and other dangerous substances.21. Volcanic AshFreaked

Share this article:

Facebook icon Pinterest icon Tumblr icon Link icon Twitter icon

Related Articles

Craziest Tweets From This Week That Will Have You Snorting Your Morning Coffee

Craziest Tweets From This Week That Will Have You Snorting Your Morning Coffee

Woman Starts Wildfires Just To Flirt With Responding Firefighters

Woman Starts Wildfires Just To Flirt With Responding Firefighters

Take A Look At The Most Outrageous Pregnancy Announcements That Redefine ‘Awkward’

Take A Look At The Most Outrageous Pregnancy Announcements That Redefine ‘Awkward’

50 "Forbidden Food" You Should Never Put On Your Plate

50 "Forbidden Food" You Should Never Put On Your Plate

21 Terrifying Medical Facts That Will Haunt You For Days

21 Terrifying Medical Facts That Will Haunt You For Days

50 Absurd and Bizarre Emails People Actually Wrote

50 Absurd and Bizarre Emails People Actually Wrote

12 Outrageous Reality Shows You Won’t Believe Actually Existed

12 Outrageous Reality Shows You Won’t Believe Actually Existed

YouTuber Risks It All To Spend 24 Hours On ‘World’s Deadliest Island’ Where Breathing Could Kill You

YouTuber Risks It All To Spend 24 Hours On ‘World’s Deadliest Island’ Where Breathing Could Kill You

22 Instances Of Target Employees Facing Outrageous And Disrespectful Customers

22 Instances Of Target Employees Facing Outrageous And Disrespectful Customers

31 Eerie Abandoned Spots Ideal For Solitude Seekers

31 Eerie Abandoned Spots Ideal For Solitude Seekers

Check Out This Mysterious Forbidden Island In New York Where No One Has Set Foot In Half A Century

Check Out This Mysterious Forbidden Island In New York Where No One Has Set Foot In Half A Century

21 People Reveal The Strangest And Most Heartwarming Things They Inherited

21 People Reveal The Strangest And Most Heartwarming Things They Inherited

Japanese Researchers Win Ig Nobel Prize For Uncovering A Crazy Secret About Mammals

Japanese Researchers Win Ig Nobel Prize For Uncovering A Crazy Secret About Mammals

Job Titles So Ridiculous, You Won’t Believe They’re Real

Job Titles So Ridiculous, You Won’t Believe They’re Real

21 Staple Foods That Are Actually So Bizarre, You’ll Wonder Who Ate Them First And Lived To Tell

21 Staple Foods That Are Actually So Bizarre, You’ll Wonder Who Ate Them First And Lived To Tell

27 Silly Questions From ‘Yahoo Answers’ That Prove Common Sense Is Not So Common After-all

27 Silly Questions From ‘Yahoo Answers’ That Prove Common Sense Is Not So Common After-all

The Twisted Tale Of How Gruesome Prop From ‘Se7en’ Reappeared In ‘Contagion’ Many Years Later

The Twisted Tale Of How Gruesome Prop From ‘Se7en’ Reappeared In ‘Contagion’ Many Years Later

Swiss Government Is Asking People To Bury Underwear—Maybe You Should Do It Too

Swiss Government Is Asking People To Bury Underwear—Maybe You Should Do It Too

Raw And Unfiltered Glimpses Into The Lives Of 21 Everyday Americans Through Photos Of Their Most Intimate Spaces

Raw And Unfiltered Glimpses Into The Lives Of 21 Everyday Americans Through Photos Of Their Most Intimate Spaces

From Surgery To 'Third State' — Woman Describes Her Profound Afterlife Experience

From Surgery To 'Third State' — Woman Describes Her Profound Afterlife Experience

What Happened When Famous Artist Gave Her Audience Complete Control Over Her Body—And A Gun

What Happened When Famous Artist Gave Her Audience Complete Control Over Her Body—And A Gun

Honeymoon Turns Chaotic After Bride Uncovers One "Small" Secret About Her Husband

Honeymoon Turns Chaotic After Bride Uncovers One "Small" Secret About Her Husband

Reality Star Loses Love Island Hosting Gig After The "Scary Surgery" She Got In Turkey Altered Her Appearance

Reality Star Loses Love Island Hosting Gig After The "Scary Surgery" She Got In Turkey Altered Her Appearance

Discover The Tropical Island That Tourist Are Banned From Visiting—Find Out Why No One Can Set Foot Here

Discover The Tropical Island That Tourist Are Banned From Visiting—Find Out Why No One Can Set Foot Here

Cops Threaten To Harm Man’s Dog To Extract False Confession, He Gets $900,000 For Emotional Damages

Cops Threaten To Harm Man’s Dog To Extract False Confession, He Gets $900,000 For Emotional Damages

Flight Crew Kicks Women Off Plane For Wearing Crop Tops

Flight Crew Kicks Women Off Plane For Wearing Crop Tops

Categories

Funny Animals Interesting Freaky Pop Culture

Business

About Us Advertise Contact Us

Legal

Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy DMCA Removal
 Logo
About Us Privacy DMCA Removal Contact Us Terms Funny Animals Interesting Freaky Pop Culture

© 2025 - All Rights Reserved

 logo

Sign In to

facebook icon Sign in with facebook
facebook icon Sign in with google

Or sign in with email

Need an account? Sign Up

Forgot Password?

By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service

 logo

Sign Up to

Already have an account? Sign In

By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service

Edit profile

User Photo